The etiology and symptoms of endodontic cases treated in
a university clinic in Saudi Arabia
A.S. Al-Yahya, BDS,
MS*, H.A. Selirn, BFS, MS**,
E.E. Guile, BSc, DMD, MPH
* Lecturer, Division of Endodontics & Director of Clinics, King Saud University, College of Dentistry,
Address reprint requests to: Dr. A.S. At-Yahya, P.O. Box
60169, Riyadh 11545, Saudi Arabia
** Lecturer, Division of Endodontics,
College of Dentistry,
King Saud University, Saudi Arabia
***Assistant Professor & Head
Division of Community Dentistry, College
of Dentistry, King Saud University, Saudi
Arabia.
Endodontic patients treated at a
University Dental Clinic over a two-year period were studied. A total of 281
patients seen in a beginning endodontic course were analyzed to determine 1)
the etiology of the pul-pal disease presenting, and 2) the signs and symptoms
of pulpal disease. Results indicated that caries was the most prevalent reason
for endodontic treatment. Most cases (40.6%) were asymptomatic. Lower molars
were the most commonly affected and there was no significant difference in
endodontic treatment distribution between males and females in the patient
population studied.
Root canal treatment (RCT) has become a stan dard
component of dental therapy today and can be performed on any tooth of the
dental arch.
The field of endodontics has expanded
in recent years. Conservative treatment with the intention of keeping the
natural dentition, as well as simplifica tion of treatment, are the main
goals. Some of the principles stated more than 30 years ago are still valid
while others are still having a great role so far in successful endodontic
treatment1.
There are incredible strides made by clinical endodontics in the past four
decades and endodontics has become a highly predictable and successful phase of
dental practice2.
Fear of RCT has greatly diminished and pain control is very effective. Treat
ment techniques are becoming confined, success rates have increased enormously
and a large number of specialists and well-trained general dentists are
practicing endodontics in their daily practice with high success rate.2 However, this success is related to our more
recent understanding of the biological basis of endodontics in the light of
bacteriologic and immunologic developments that lead to proper diagnosis, total
tooth isolation, adequate access, total caries removal, thorough debridement,
irrigation, and complete obturation of root canal.3
Dental caries is the primary cause of endodontics despite the
evident decline of caries incidence.4,5,6 Trauma, as well as other factors, are
causing a high demand for endodontic therapy.4,5,7
In Saudi Arabia
there is evidence that caries is prevalent in a large percentage of the
population. By the age of 12, only 41.9% of children are free of caries in
permanent teeth.8 A study of teeth treated for endodontics in Riyadh indicated that
many of them had previously untreated caries and poor restorations with
secondary caries.9.
Pulpal disease is a significant problem in Saudi Arabia.
Information about the pulpally-involved dental disease in the University could
serve as a pointer to this disease as a national health problem.
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the causes, signs and
symptoms of endodontic cases presented in King
Saud University,
College of Dentistry student clinics.
Patients presenting for treatment at the student
endodontic clinics of KSU were evaluated for etiol ogy and signs and symptoms
of pulpal disease. A total of two hundred eighty-one (281) patients were
examined and treated endodontically.
The examination was performed by students in the entry
level Endodontics course under direct supervision of endodontic specialist
clinical instructors. Patients were also required to fill an information sheet,
indicating the chief complaint: type of pain, intensity, severity in addition
to the routine dental and relevant medical histories. Clin ical and
radiographic examinations were per
formed in order to determine the pulpal and periapical status. Vitality tests
performed included both thermal and electric pulp testings. Since this was the
first clinical course in endodontics, selec tion of the cases were conducted
according to the following criteria:
1. Simple cases only
with straight canals. Curved, calcified and difficult cases were eliminated and
referred to advanced courses.
2. Cases with previous conventional treatment or requiring surgical
approach were not used.
After diagnosis and treatment, cases were classified
according to three (3) main groups:
Group I included the tooth type according to
loca tion. These included the upper or iower anterior, bicuspids and molars.
Group II included six (6) age
categorized sub groups as follows: < 14, 15 to 24, 25 to 34, 35 to 44, 45
to 54, and over 55.
In Group III, the cases were
categorized by gender, to determine if there was sex difference in the
distribution of endodontic cases. Groups I, II, and 111 were analyzed in
relation to the following vari ables: 1} various reasons for endodontics and
2) clinical signs and symptoms. The chi-square test was used for statistical
analysis.
The reason for endodontic treatment covered a spectrum of
factors from caries to previous failed endodontic care. The major reason for
endodontic treatment was caries (52.6% of the total patients). The second major
reason for endodontic treatment was trauma (17.4% of the total patients) {Table
1)
The group which had the highest
number of caries-caused endodontic treatment was the 15-24 age group (37.8%).
This period is peak for caries attack10 and also
reflects the largest proportion of the population. There is a gradual decrease
of caries-caused endodontic treatment as reflected in the 55+ years age group
which accounted for 5.4% of cases treated. These latter are possibly due
to root surface caries.
Trauma as a cause for endodontic treatment was present
preponderantly in the group, 15-24 years (48.9%) and also declined with age to
10.2% in the 45-54 year-age group.
There were more male patients treated
for endodontics than females (Figure 1). There were only eight teeth needing
endodontic treatment for periodontal reasons, and five teeth needing endodontic
treatment because of mechanical exposure. For the rest of the variables the
reasons for endodontics were comparable in both male and female patients
(Figure 1).
The signs and symptoms of endodontic cases by age (Table
2) showed that the majority of this cate gory were in the 15-24 years
age-group (33.9%). Acute pain was also more common in this same group. Chronic
pain shifted to a slightly higher age with 34% in both 15-24 and 25-34 year
age-
groups.
Sinus involvement was present in 29.2% of 35-44 years
age-group indicating that the middle ages were more at risk for sinus
invo!vement( Table 2). Spontaneous pain associated with endodontic problems was
more common in 25-34 year-old patients. There were, however, only forty-one
cases who experienced spontaneous pain (Table 1).
Since overdentures are required by
older ages,it was found that 54.1 % of the cases were 45-54 age-group, and 33.3%
of them were 55 years of age and older (Table 1). The highest frequency of
signs and symptoms was asymptomatic (38.3% with the male and 37.7% with
female). This response matched with the high percentage of cases having necrotic
pulp when different vitality tests were used. Differences between males and
females, in respect of all signs and symptoms, were found not to be
statistically significant (Figure 2).
Caries as the cause of endodontic treatment was more
common in lower molars than any other tooth type. This was followed by upper
anteriors. Upper anteriors were the most commonly affected teeth by trauma.
Lower molars and upper anteriors were equally affected by
spontaneous pain (Table 3). Lower molars were the teeth primarily affected by
acute pain while upper anteriors had more chronic pain (Table 4).
The information about endodontic cases which were presented for
treatment at the King Saud Uni versity clinic provided some insights
into factors surrounding pulpal diseases in Saudi Arabia. The clinic treats a
diverse and large target population. However, this study did not have a
representative sample of the general population.
The result indicated that the reason
for endodon tic treatment was primarily dental caries. The caries' attack rate
for the adolescence and young adults was relatively high8 and probably rising. Trauma-related endodontic
treatments were traced to the high rate of maxillofacial trauma from road
traffic accidents. The twenty-four cases which resulted from overdenture
reflected deliberate endodontic treatment and not the presence of pul pal
disease. The few cases which were caused by mechanical exposure reflected the
limited experi ence of the clinicians in this early level course.
Most cases were asymptomatic (N = 106). The most common symptom
experienced for endodontic cases was acute pain. Sinus involve ment was
primarily in the 34-45 years age-group.
The distribution by tooth type revealed that lower molars were in
greatest need for endodontic treatment due to caries. This corresponds to early
eruption of lower molars causing a greater risk of caries in this population.
In this study there was no statistically significant associations between age,
sex, tooth type and reasons for endodontic treatment (p > .05). There was
also no significant association between age, sex or tooth type, and signs and
symptoms of the disease.
An analysis of cases treated in a beginning level
endodontic course at King
Saud University
revealed that:
-
The most common etiology of pulpal
disease was dental caries.
-
The teeth most commonly affected were upper anterior and
lower molars respectively.
-
There were no gender differences in the distri bution of
pulpal disease in the patient popula tion studied.
- Grossman L. Rationale of Endodontic
treatment. Dent. Clin. of North Am, Nov. 1967: 483-90.
-
Schilder H. The
Current clinical endodontics. J. Endodontics, 1983; 12:389-99.
-
Brothman P. Getting back to basics: an endodontist's view
on endodontic practice and education. JDC Dent Soc, 1979;54:7-9.
-
Davies A. et al.
Oral Health Status in United
States: will improved health lead to
decreased demand for dental services. J Dent Educ, 1985; 49(6):427-31.
-
Sales D. In Response; oral health status in the United States
the prevalence of dental caries.J Dent Educ, 1985; 49(6).
-
Burt B. The future of the caries decline. J of Pub Health
Dent, 45(4):261-69.
-
Taintorj et al. Endodontic Considerations of overdenture.
J Nebr Dent
Assoc 1978;55:11-20.
-
Guile E, Al-Shammery R, El-Backly M. Caries status among
school children in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. Abstracts, Fifth
Saudi Dental Meeting; Feb. 29-March 3, 1988.
-
Selim H. Restorative history of endodontically treated
teeth, personal communication.
-
Kelly JE, Harves
CR. Decayed, missing and filled teeth among persons 1-74 years. United States 1971-1974.
Washington , DC. Govt Printing Off. 1981; Publ. No. (PHS)
81-1
|