Maxillofacial Trauma In Kuwait: A Retrospective Study
(1985-1989)
Bader E. At Mahmeed, BDS*;
Robert E. Morris, DDS, MPH**;
Ibrahim M. Al Yassrn,BDS**;
Mohamed S. Belal, BDS**; Abbas Al-Ramzy, BDS**;
Bader Al Rasheed, BDS**; Sohail M. Al Yassin, BDS**
* Director of Dental Services, Ministry ofPublic Health, Kuwait.
** Dental Services Department, Ministry of Public Health,
P.O. Box 11214, Dasmah 35153 Kuwait.
The patterns of maxillofacial trauma in Kuwait from 1985 to 1989 are
compared. The incidence of trauma to children appears greater than in other
countries reporting such data. In Kuwait, the age group 15-19 has the
highest rate of trauma. The male-female ratio is similar to other countries.
Violence or assault is not considered an etiological factor in Kuwait. The
health and economic loss to Kuwait
needs to be determined.
With the increasing modernization of Kuwait in the
early 1980's, the Ministry of Public Health observed an increase in
maxillofacial injuries admitted to the public hospitals. In response to the
increased treatment needs, the government developed the Maxillofacial Trauma
Unit at the Specialist Dental Center
in Kuwait City.
Previous studies have reported that maxillofacial injuries
to children in Kuwait appears to be the highest in the world.1,2 Age of injured children ranged from birth to
12 years. The chief causes of these injuries are road traffic accidents and
falls in and around the house.
In this study, the aetiology of all maxillofacial injuries
admitted to the Unit from 1985 to 1989, and their types and treatment rendered
were examined.
A retrospective review of the maxillofacial trauma experience of the
Maxillofacial Trauma Unit was undertaken. The 352 files of all patients
admitted to the unit from January 1985 to December 1989 were examined. Patients
with only tooth injuries or patients who . ed were excluded. Injuries were
defined as fractures of the paranasal sinuses, nasal bones, maxilla, or
mandible. Data collected on each case included age, sex, nationality, etiology,
location, type of injury, associated injuries and treatment provided.
Comparisons of the different age-groups were then made to define similarities
and differences
The age-group 15-19 had the highest incidence of
maxillofacial trauma -21.9% (77/352, p= .005 [Fig. 1|) and the specific case
rate was 53.03/ 100,000 [Fig. 2], which is the highest among all age-groups.
The 14 and younger age-group represented 13.64% (48/352) of the admissions. The
ratio of male to female victims is approximately 4:1 [Fig. 3]. The percentage
of victims by nationality is consistent with the population estimates for Kuwaitis
and non-Kuwaiti Arabs, while percentage of injured among non-Arabs was lower
relative to their population ratio [Fig. 4].
Road traffic accidents (71 %, 139/196) is by far the
primary cause of maxillofacial trauma
[Fig. 5]. Violence is not
reported as an etiological factor.
res are near equally divided between the middle face
and the mandible [Fig. 61. Injuries to the mandible were 46.2% of total
injuries; the body of the mandible being the specific site most often injured -
21.7% [Fig. 6a]. In the maxilla, the alveolus was the primary siteof
injury-16.3%. The highest percentage of associated injuries occurred in the
long bones - 31% (Table 1). Arch bar stabilization was the most prevalent
treatment method-59.3% [Fig. 7].
In Kuwait,
accidents involving motor vehicles and in and around the house are the major
etiological factors in maxillofacial trauma. The percentage of cases involving
children continues to far exceed the rates reported in other countries with
available data.3 The specific rate for the 15- to 19-year-old
age-group greatly exceeds any other age-group (p = 0.003). It seems that males
of this age-group are most likely to be injured regardless of the reason, be it
a motor car in Kuwait or a
fist in England.
In a study of tooth related injuries to patients younger
than 20 years in Finland, only 11% was caused by traffic accidents while
another 11 % was caused by violence.4 Interestingly, in Kuwait, violence is not
considered an etiological factor. This finding may well be inaccurate as the
patient may not be able to relate the entire truth about the causes of the
injury. Additionally, it is possible that the hospital chart causes a bias in
its reporting by noting (a) the cause of injury and (b) the driver or
passenger. The juxtaposition of these questions could bias the answers. In England,
violence is a major cause of such injuries.5
The percentage of road traffic accident of all causes has
increased from 56% in 1980-84 to 71 % in 1985-89. This percentage is similar to
the reported rates in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.6 The rate of injuries involving females in
Kuwait increased from 12.9% in 1980-84 to 19% and is similar to the rates in
USA, England, and Saudi Arabia6,7,8 The
increase reflects the continuing integration of women into the social and
economic affairs in the Kuwait's society. The incidence of injuries to the
mandible is similar to the findings in other studies (32-53%), while fractures
to the maxilla (30%) are far greater than reported in Riyadh (13.6%) or Tayside(4.4%).3,5,6
This high rate of maxillary fractures can be attributed to
injuries caused by contact with the windshield or other interior components of
the car. In the United
States, automobile glass is considered the
leading cause of facial injuries in automobile crashes.9
Economic prosperity from oil has brought rapid
industrialization to Kuwait
with its concomitant problems. The increased number of motor vehicles has led
to an increase in road traffic accidents.10,11 This increase is reflected in the
high incidence of maxillofacial trauma, especially in the under-20-year-old
age-group. While Kuwait
roads are considered among the best in the world, car accidents have continued
to increase since the 1980-84 period. Children and young adults are
inordinately involved in these accidents. The percentage of 15-19-year-olds
involved reinforces the community perception of both illegal and poorly trained
drivers. Unfortunately, there is also an increased rate of females suffering
from these injuries, about 47% more than what has been reported for the 1980-84
period.
Injuries remain the leading cause of death during the
first four decades of life.12 The toll
in death and disability is rivalled only by the high cost to society in lost
productivity and wasted utilization of scarce resources. Kuwait is a
wealthy country, yet this economic loss to society from unexpected injuries and
death remains unacceptable. While road safety promotions exists in Kuwait, this
report indicates that society does not heed to it. Strengthening the laws,
traffic regulations, and driver education programs are essential. The
effectiveness of restraints in reducing the frequency of facial injuries is
well documented.
Further studies are needed to elucidate the role of
violence in these injuries. Better documentation of the injuries and its
causes, and the use of seat belts by drivers and passengers are required. The
cost to society remains unmeasured and precautionary measures need to be taken
to effectively eliminate such injuries and death.
Our thanks to Nely A. Vicente for typing the manuscript.
- Al Yassin
JM, Al Mahmeed BE, Morris RE, et al. The aetiology of maxillofacial fractures
in children from birth to 12 years in Kuwait. J Kuwait Med
Assoc September 1990. (Publication delayed by war).
-
Al Yassin
IM, Al Mahmeed BE, Al Ramzi A, et al. Maxillofacial trauma in Kuwait from
1980 to 1984. Proceedings of the Kuwait International Dental
Conference. Kuwait,
1986:
-
Gussak GS,
Luterman A, Powell RW, et ai. Pediatric maxillofacial trauma. Unique features
in diagnosis and treatment. Laryngoscope 1987;97:926-30.
-
Oakarinen
K, Kassila O. Causes and types of traumatic tooth injuries in a public dental
health clinic. J Dent Que 1989;26(l):19-24.
-
Hagan EK,
Hulke DF. An analysis of 319 case fractures. J Oral Surg Anest Hosp DentServ
1971; 19:93.
-
Brown RD, Cowpe JG. Patterns of maxillofacial trauma in two different
cultures. A comparison between Riyadh
and Tayside. J R Coll Surg Edinb 1985;30(5):299-302.
-
Ellis E,
Moos KF, El Attar A. Ten years of mandibular fractures. An analysis of 2,137
cases. Oral Surg 1985;59(2):120-9.
-
Bochlogyros
PN. A retrospective study of 1,521 mandibular fractures. J Oral Maxillofac Surg
1935;43(8):597-9.
-
Huelke DF,
Compton CP. Facial injuries in automobile crashes. J Oral Maxillofac Surg
1983;41:241 -4.
-
Source: World Health Organization.
-
Arab
Times. Kuwait accidents rate highest despite laws. December 10, 1989.
-
Baker SP.
Medical data and injuries. Am | Publ Health 1983;73(7):733-4.
|