|
Pattern Of Tooth Loss In A Selected Population At
King Saud University College Of Dentistry
Ayodeji T. Idowu, BDS, MS, Saleh M. Al-Shamrani, BDS, MS
King Saud University College of Dentistry, P.O. Box 60169, Riyadh 11545, Saudi Arabia.
The pattern of tooth loss was investigated in a selected segment of
Saudi population. The study covered 1, 1 73 Saudi patients, aged 15-85
years, who attended the dental screening clinics of the College of
Dentistry, King Saud University in Riyadh between 1990-1992. Tooth loss
was found to increase steadily with age. There was a slight tendency
for higher tooth mortality among the females. The mandibular first
molars were the most frequently missing (accounting for 41.5% of the
total missing teeth), while the mandibular canines were the longest
retained (accounting for 9.1 % of the total missing teeth). The
anterior teeth were more often missing in the maxillary than in the
mandibular, while the molars were more often missing in the reverse
order. There was an abrupt increase in tooth mortality after the ages
35-44.
The
pattern of tooth loss has been generally regarded as one of the most important
measures for assessing the standard, availability and utilization of both
curative and preventive dental care in a given population.12
Most national surveys on patterns of tooth loss have found a linear
relationship between increase in age and loss of teeth. However, there are still great regional
differences in the prevalence of toothlessness in the world.13"12
The two most important biological factors responsible
for tooth loss are dental caries (which accounts for most teeth lost in early
life) and periodontal disease (which accounts for most teeth loss in later
life). In the last three decades, most efforts of the dental profession in the
industrialized nations have been directed towards the treatment and prevention
of these diseases. As a result, a dramatic decline in edentulousness with age
has now been documented.1314
Little, if any, is known about the patterns of tooth loss
in any segment of the Saudi population. The purpose of this study was,
therefore, to investigate the patterns of tooth loss in a selected adult Saudi population.
The study involved 1,173 Saudi patients, age 15- 85
years, who attended the dental screening clinics at the College
of Dentistry, King
Saud University,
Riyadh between
1990-1992. The sample was obtained by random selection of patient files from records
stored in serial order. The clinical examinations and radiographs, taken after
the first visit to the dental clinics, were used as the source of information
on age, sex, teeth present and missing. The number of teeth present and missing
were recorded from full mouth periapical radiographs and orthopantomograms. As
in other studies, third molars were excluded from this study on account of
their frequent impaction tendencies or agenesis. Retained roots and impacted
teeth were considered as non-existing teeth.
The relationship between missing teeth and age was
assessed by correlation analysis. Inter-arch and sex differences in tooth
mortality were discerned by f-test.
Table 1 shows the distribution of patients in each age
group. A fairly constant direct relationship (r = 0.69) was found between
increase in age and mean number of missing individual teeth in both sexes [Fig.l]
and was statistically significant (P < 0.0001). The mandibular first molars
were found to be the most frequently missing at 41.5%, while the mandibular
canines were found to be the longest retained teeth at 41.5% and at 9.1% of the
total missing teeth [Fig.2]. In the region from the central incisors to the
first premolars, there was a tendency for more maxillary teeth to be missing
than the mandibular teeth and the trend reverses from the second
premolar teeth [Fig.2]. The inter- arch differences have been found to be
statistically significant (P < 0.0001).
Loss of Individual
Anterior Teeth, [Figs. 3-5]
There was a low tooth mortality rate of anterior teeth
(centrals, laterals and canines) among younger age-groups (from 15-24 to
35-44). However, from 35-44-year age-group to > 74 year-olds, the tooth
mortality rate rose sharply with the female anterior teeth more often retained.
The sex differences were statistically significant (P < 0.0001).
Loss of Individual
Posterior Teeth, [Figs. 6-9]
No significant sex differences were found in tooth
mortality rate among the first and second premolars.
The female mandibular first and second molars were the
most often missing, while the male maxillary first and second molars were the
longest retained within individual tooth types. This sex differences were found
to be statistically significant (P< 0.0001).
With increasing age, the percentage of people with more
than 15 missing teeth increased from 0.81% at 15-24-year-old age-group to 78.6%
in the > 74-year-old age-group and from 0% at 15- 24-year-old age-group to
100% at > 74-year-old age-group in males and females, respectively. Abrupt
increase in tooth mortality was noticeable after the ages of 35-44 in which
males had 6.2% and females had 8.2% of more than 15 teeth missing (Table 2).
This study provides a profile of tooth loss in a selected
Saudi adult population. Generally, the direct relationship between the increase
in age and the loss of teeth found in this study is consistent with the usually
observed patterns of tooth loss.
The tendency for higher tooth loss in females than in
males is consistent with some studies,14 but not
with others.7-15 The higher level of tooth mortality in
women has been attributed in some countries to the more frequent dental visits
by females for care of inadequate and unaesthetic dentition4 rather
than to a true reflection of a higher tooth mortality than the male
counterpart.
Not surprisingly, the first molar was found to be the
most commonly missing while the canine was the longest retained. Early loss of
molars relative to other teeth has been generally attributed to their early
eruption and vulnerability to caries.1216
The low mortality rate of the anterior teeth, in the younger
age-groups up to the fourth decade, is an indication that the need for
aesthetic replacement of missing teeth will be uncommon among young adults.
Although caries is still regarded as the leading cause of tooth loss, the loss
of anterior teeth is attributed predominantly to periodontal disease while loss
of posterior teeth is attributed predominantly to caries.2'517"19
A notable finding of interarch difference in the pattern
of tooth loss, which is consistent with other studies,7'121520
was that anteriors and first premolars were more frequently missing in the maxillary
than in the mandibular arch and molars were more frequently missing in the
latter than in the former. Higher mortality of maxillary premolars compared to
mandibular premolars is thought to be due to the relatively higher resistance
of the mandibular premolars to dental caries.1216
The tendency for the molars to be more frequently missing coupled with
the mandibular molars having higher tooth mortality than maxillary molars as
demonstrated in this study may explain why mandibular distal extension partial
dentures have been found to be the most common type of removable partial
dentures.20-21
Moreover, the likelihood of finding more females with
mandibular distal extensions than males in this study is higher since they tend
to have a higher mandibular molar tooth mortality.
The observation of an abrupt increase in tooth mortality
levels after the 35-44-year- old age-group in the present study is in agreement
with others122 and is consistent with the progress of periodontal disease
that finally takes its toll on the dentition in the latter decades of life.2324
In the comparison of the mean numbers of missing teeth
among different countries, the degree of tooth loss in this study was close to
that observed in other populations in developing countries1'2'525
but certainly higher than that observed in the USA study.15
Recent studies have found a remarkable reduction in tooth mortality among
populations in industrialized countries as a result of improved dental services
in conjunction with an increased public awareness of matters relating to oral health.10-1315
In contrast, an oral health survey of Saudi Arabia has shown that the incidence
of caries increases with age along with a worsening of the periodontal status.26
This finding therefore underscores the importance and supports the recommendation
of introducing a more comprehensive preventive measures and improving oral
health care among Saudi communities.26 It is worth noting, however,
that the data in this and other similar studies are cross- sectional and
differences have to be interpreted with caution, as emphasis can only be placed
on trends rather than the qualitative aspects.
The
authors gratefully acknowledge the valuable comments and suggestions offered by
Professor E.S. Akpata, Director of the Restorative Dentistry Graduate Program,
King Saud University, College of Dentistry. Thanks are also due to Dr. Nazeer Khan,
Biostatistician of the College's Research Center, for providing statistical
assistance and to Ms. Vilma S. Dizon for typing the manuscript.
-
Ekanayaka A. Tooth mortality in plantation workers and residents in Sri
Lanka Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 1984;12:128-35.
-
Manji F, Baelum V, Fejerskov O. Tooth mortality in an adult
rural population in Kenya J Dent Res 1988;67:496- 500.
-
Cohen LK. International comparisons in the provision of
oral health care. Br Dent J 1980;149:347-51.
-
Clarkson JJ, O'Mullane DM. Edentulousness in the United Kingdom and Ireland. Community Dent Oral
Epidemiol 1983;11:317-20.
-
Baelum V, Fejerskov O. Tooth loss as related to dental caries
and periodontal breakdown in adult Tanzanians. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol
1986;14:353-57.
-
Hobdell MH, Sheiham A, Slack GL. Patterns of tooth loss
in British populations. Studies on National Health Service patients. Br Dent J
1969;126:349-51.
-
Saunders RH, Solomon ES, Handelman SL. Relationship of
age to tooth loss in a chronic care facility. Spec Care Dentist 1982;2:25-30.
-
Crabb HS. Tooth mortality in a selected population. A survey
of patients attending the Conservation Department of a teaching hospital. Br
Dent J 1966;121:553-60.
-
Edmunds DH, Crabb HSM. Five-year review of tooth mortality
in a selected population in Leeds, U.K. Commumity
Dent Oral Epidemiol 1975;3:64-68.
-
Faulkner RK, Crabb HSM. Tooth mortality in a selected population
in Leeds, UK. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol
1983;11:375-78.
-
Vital and Health Statistics Series II No. 7 USDHEW Publication
No. 74-1274,1973 p.7.
-
Agagnon-Varelzides A, Komboli M, Tsami A, Mitsis F. Pattern
of tooth loss in a selected population in Greece. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol
1986;14:349-52.
-
LoeH. Dentitry in the 21st Century. A Global
Perspective. Proceeding of the International Symposium on Dentistry in the 21st
Century. Berlin,
Sept. 10, 1987; 13-23 (Edt) Richard Simonsen Quintessence Publ. Co., Chicago.
-
Renson CE, Crielaers PJA, Ibikunle SA, Pinto VG, Ross
CB, Infirri JS, Takazoe I, Tala H. Changing patterns of oral health and
implications for oral health manpower. Part
I. Report of a working group convened
jointly by the Federation Dentaire Internationale and the WHO. Int DentJ
1985;35:235-51.
-
Meskin LH, Brown LJ. Prevalence and patterns of tooth loss
in US employed adult and senior populations. J Dent Educ 1988;52:686-691.
-
Berman DS, Slack GL. Susceptibility of tooth surfaces
to carious attack. A longitudinal study. Br Dent J 1973;134:135-39.
-
1
7. Krogh HW. Permanent tooth mortality: A clinical study of causes of loss. J
Am Dent Assoc 1958;57:670-75.
-
Andrews G, Krogh HW. Permanent tooth mortality. Dent Prog 1961;1:130-34.
-
Okoisor
FE. Tooth Mortality: A clinical study of causes of loss. Nig Med J
1977;7:77-81.
-
Owall
BE, Taylor RL. A survery of dentitions and removable partial dentures
constructed for patients in North America. J Prosthet Dent 1989;61:465-70.
-
Curtis DA, Curtis TA, Wagnild GW, Finzen FC. Incidence of various
classes of removable partial dentures. J Prosthet Dent 1992;67:664-67.
-
Sheiham A, Hobdell MH, Cowell CR. Patterns of tooth loss
in British populations. Studies on industrial populations. Br Dent J
1969;126:255-60.
-
Loe
H, Anerud A, Boysen H, Smith M. The natural history of periodontal disease in
man. Tooth mortality rates before 40 years of age. J Periodontal Res 1978;
13:563- 72.
-
Loe
H, Anerud A, Boysen H, Smith M. The natural history of periodontal disease in
man. The rate of periodontal destruction before 40 years of age. J Periodontol 1978;49:607-20.
-
Naylor
MN, Curwen MP. The mortality of permanent teeth. Br Dent J 1967; 123:541.
-
Al-Shammery
A, Guile E, El-Backly M, Lamborne A. An oral health survey of Saudi Arabia:
Phase I (Riyadh). Monograph: KingSaud University, 1991.

|