Management of Rampant Caries in Saudi Adults
- Case Reports
Maha Nahass, BDS, E.S. Akpata, BChD, MDSc, FDS, FWACS
King Saud University College of Dentistry, P.O. Box 60169, Riyadh 11545, Saudi Arabia.
Rampant caries in adult patients is not
uncommon in dental clinics in Saudi Arabia. To gain the patients'
confidence and cooperation, early stages of management should include
improvement of the appearance of carious anterior teeth by placing
aesthetic provisional restorations using, for example, glass ionomer
cements. After emergency treatment, definitive restorative management
should commence only when the patients have demonstrated compliance
with oral health education, including caries preventive measures.
Analysis of dietary habits and assessment of salivary function are
important in diagnosing factors that predispose the disease. Two cases
of rampant caries in adult Saudi patients are presented to highlight
these features in managing the condition.
Rampant
caries may be defined as a lesion of acute onset affecting practically all
erupted teeth, including those normally resistant to caries attack, such as the
mandibular incisors.1 The carious lesions spread rapidly and may
soon involve the pulp. Most affected patients develop five or more lesions a
year.2'3 It has been suggested that there is a high
probability that permanent teeth will be affected in mose who suffer from the
disease in the primary dentition, unless successful preventive measures were
implemented.4
In young adults, rampant caries may result from frequent
consumption of cariogenic diet, such as cakes, chocolates and sugar-sweetened
carbonated drinks. The carious lesions appear typically on buccal and lingual
surfaces of premolars and molars as well as approximal and labial surfaces of mandibular
incisors.5 In adults, the disease is often associated with salivary
gland hypofunction, due to irradiation of the head and neck region.4 Occasionally,
salivary gland hypofunction results from the use of antisialogogic drugs or
impaired emotional states.6 Multiple cervical carious lesions are
typical, although extensive occlusal and approximal cavities may also be
present. Where there has been gingival recession, root caries may be seen,
especially in the elderly.
There
is considerable literature on rampant caries in children1,6 but
little appears to have been written on the management of this condition in adults. In Saudi Arabia,
we frequently see adult patients with rampant caries in our clinics, but most
of these patients have apparently normal salivary gland function. We,
therefore, present two of our cases with the aim of highlighting the
characteristic features in clinical presentation and management of patients
with the disease in Saudi
Arabia.
Case 1
A 24-year-old male Saudi typist presented at our clinic
at King Saud University College of Dentistry, complaining of poor appearance
due to discoloration and breakdown of his anterior teeth. He had visited many
dentists but had not received satisfactory treatment. The patient had no
toothache or any complaint about his general health. He looked well nourished
and was not obese. However, the appearance of his teeth posed a psychological problem:
he avoided smiling and lacked self-confidence. Clinical examination showed that
all his teeth were badly broken down by caries [Fig. 1] or had defective
restorations with recurrent caries. However, no tooth was tender to percussion
and the pulps of all his teeth responded positively on testing for vitality.
There was generalized periodontitis and bleeding index was 100%. All quadrants
showed heavy plaque accumulation. The patient produced copious watery saliva.
Apart from the use of miswak (chewing stick) once a month, he practiced no form
of oral hygiene. Radiographic examination showed no significant alveolar bone
loss and there were no periapical radiolucent areas.
After making a diagnosis of rampant caries, the nature
of the disease was explained to the patient. At this first visit, caries was
excavated from anterior teeth [Fig. 2] and provisional glass ionomer cement restorations
placed to improve his appearance immediately. Particular attention was paid to finishing
of the gingival margins of the provisional restorations to minimize further
plaque accumulation. In addition, gingival embrasures were maintained to
facilitate interproximal cleaning. After oral hygiene instructions, dietary
record sheets were given to the patient to be completed on three consecutive
days, including a week-end day.
Analysis of the three-day dietary diary at the second
visit revealed that the patient drank about 16 cups of tea over a period of two hours three times a day. Each cup
(about 25 ml) contained two cubes of sugar. The tea-drinking habit was
accompanied by snacks which comprised mainly nuts but no cakes or chocolates. After explaining to the patient the roll of his sugar consumption pattern in the aetiology of rampant caries, he
was advised on the need to greatly reduce his sugar consumption and intensify his
oral hygiene practices, i.e. brushing with fluoride toothpaste. The oral
hygiene measures were to be practiced before and after each meal or snack and before
bed. He was also requested to bring along to the clinic the prescribed oral
hygiene aids.
At the third visit three weeks later, the patient's compliance
with oral hygiene instruction and dietary counselling were assessed: plaque
index was measured; likewise dietary habit, but this time by the recall method.
Grossly carious posterior teeth were temporized by excavating caries and
placing modified zinc oxide-eugenol cement restorations. Oral health education
was reinforced. At the next two visits, the same procedures were repeated,
while small and moderate carious cavities on posterior teeth were restored with
amalgam.
When the patient was evaluated at a recall visit three
months later [Fig. 3], there was marked improvement in the periodontal
condition, the gingival index having fallen from 100% to 20%. At the recall
appointment six months later, oral hygiene was excellent. The glass ionomer
cement restorations on the anterior teeth
were then veneered with microfilled composite resin. At the one-year follow-up,
the patient had continued to maintain very good oral hygiene and the gingival
margins and papillae were healthy [Fig. 4]. Permanent restorations were then
placed on posterior teeth.
Case 2
A 40-year-old Saudi housewife complained of discolored
broken-down anterior teeth but she had no toothache. Clinical examination
revealed rampant caries with destruction of both anterior and posterior teeth.
A 3-day dietary record did not indicate excessive sugar consumption. However, her
oral hygiene was very poor and she last visited the dentist eight years ago.
Attempt at excavation of caries from her anterior teeth
resulted in pulpal exposure of tooth #21. To place an aesthetic provisional
restoration and yet maintain unimpeded access to the root canal, a gutta percha
stick was inserted into the root canal before temporary restoration with glass
ionomer cement [Figs. 5 and 6]. After the restorative material had set, the
gutta percha was removed; a cotton pellet placed in the pulp chamber and the
access cavity sealed with Cavit, synthetic resin temporary restorative material. This
procedure facilitated endodontic treatment later.
Gross caries on posterior teeth was controlled by placing
temporary glass ionomer or zinc-oxide eugenol cement restorations. Thus, the
patient found it easier to maintain good oral hygiene which resulted in
improved gingival health. More definitive restorative treatment was planned to follow
after the patient had demonstrated ability to sustain her improved oral
hygiene.
Poor oral hygiene is a common feature in adult patients
with rampant caries seen at our clinics at King Saud University College of Dentistry,
as exemplified by the two cases reported above. Furthermore, in many of our
cases, dietary analysis usually reveal high frequency of sugar consumption, although
this was not so in Case 2. Apart from the sugar in tea reported in Case 1,
cakes, chocolates and soft drinks are other sources of frequent sugar intake among
the Saudi population.7 Oral hygiene instruction and dietary
analysis, therefore, constitute important aspects in the management of adult patients
with rampant caries in the Kingdom.
The primary complaint of almost all adult patients with
rampant caries who visit our clinics is poor appearance of their anterior
teeth, and invariably, they have made unsuccessful attempts to receive satisfactory
treatment elsewhere. Hence at the first visit, we endeavor to improve their
appearance by restoring the anterior teeth provisionally with tooth colored
restorative materials such as glass ionomer cement. With the immediate
improvement in the patients' appearance, they tend to have more confidence in
the dentist and therefore cooperate by complying with oral hygiene instruction
and dietary counselling.
It is important to reinforce oral health education at
each visit. It has been demonstrated that a patient's level of oral hygiene
tends to deteriorate not long after a visit to the dentist, but improves again
after reinforcement of oral health education.8
When salivary gland hypofunction is suspected, e.g. in
patients on antisialogogic drugs,6 irradiation of the salivary
gland, or in those with thick and ropy saliva, the host's resistance to caries
should be assessed by measuring
both the resting
and stimulated
salivary flow rates as well as buffer capacity.9'10 In
the cases reported in this paper, however, salivary secretion was copious and
watery.
Lactobacilli count may be used
to assess a patient's compliance with dietary counselling: the count is usually
high in patients with high sugar consumption.1011 Furthermore, Streptococcus
mutans count may provide an insight into the patient's level
of caries activity. These microbiological
tests can now be carried out on the dental chair. The results of these tests
may also provide a rational basis for making the decision to proceed with
advanced restorative treatment, such as provision of fixed prostheses.10
Generally, we classify the management of adult patients
with rampant caries into three phases:
Phase 1
After history taking, clinical examination and diagnosis
at the first visit, anterior teeth are immediately restored with provisional
aesthetic restorations. On account of its anticariogenic property, glass
ionomer cement is the restorative material of choice.1213 The
provisional restorations take care of the patient's chief complaint which invariably
includes poor appearance. The nature of the caries process is explained to the
patient in the language he/she comprehends. The patient is then given oral
hygiene instruction and provided with forms for a 3-day dietary record,
including a week-end day.
In some cases, the patient is requested to bring his/her
oral hygiene kit to the clinic at the next visit. This helps in patient
motivation. Also, plaque disclosing tablets or solution, such as erythrocin, may
be prescribed to enable the patient assess his/her oral hygiene efforts.
Phase 2
At this phase, the patient's oral hygiene is assessed
and oral health education reinforced. The dietary record is assessed11
and if sugar consumption is found to be excessive, the patient is encouraged to
suggest realistic ways to reduce the frequency of sugar consumption. It is
emphasized that the control of the disease depends mainly on the patient's
compliance with oral health education. The patient may be given professional
oral debridement and fluoride application. At this stage, he/she is given routine
operative treatment, including
the provision
of preventive restorations and fissure sealants.
The patient is seen at three-monthly recall visits when
oral hygiene, periodontal condition and compliance with oral health education
are assessed. If new carious lesions are still appearing, in spite of improved
oral hygiene, reduced frequency of sugar intake and topical fluoride
application, 0.2% chlorhexidine mouthwash twice daily may be prescribed1415
for a period of six weeks each time. It should be remembered that prolonged use
of chlorhexidine mouthwash may cause tooth discoloration.
Phase 3
When the rampant caries has
been brought under control, periodontal condition satisfactory and the patient's
improved oral hygiene sustained, advanced restorative treatment, including crown and bridgework may be provided in phase 3 of the treatment. Where facilities are
available, microbiological caries activity tests, using the dip slide
method, are carried out not only during the first two phases, but also in
phases 3 before a decision is taken to provide advanced restorative treatment. The
patient is then seen at recall appointments twice yearly.
-
Winter GB, Hamilton MC, James PM. Role of the com- forter as an
aetiologic factor in rampant caries of the de ciduous dentition. Arch Dis Child
1966;41:207-12.
-
Tinanoff N, Klock B, Camosci DA, Manwell MA. Micro- biologic
effects of SnF2 and NaF mouthrinses in subjects with high caries activity:
results after one year. J Dent Res 1983;62:907-11.
-
Nikiforuk G. Understanding dental caries: Etiology and mechanisms.
Basic and clinical aspects. Basel:S.
Karger, 1985:9-10.
-
Levine RS, Hill FJ. Rampant caries and its management. Part
1. Clinical manifestations and aetiology. Br Dent J 1978;145:210-12.
-
Yiu CK, Wei SH. Management of rampant caries in chil- dren.
Quintessence Int 1992;23:159-68.
-
Walsh LJ, Seow WK. Fermentable simple sugars in self- administered
medicaments as aetiologic agents in rampant caries. Case report. AustrDentJ
1990;35:419-25.
-
Akpata ES, Al-Shammery AR, Saeed HI. Dental caries,
sug- ar consumption and restorative dental care in 12-13-year-old children in
Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 1992;20:343-46.
-
Elderton RJ, Hobdell MH. Results and discussion. In:
All- red H. ed. Assessment of the quality of dental care. Lon don:London
Hospital Medical College, 1977:16-40.
-
Pardo GI, Sreebny LM. Management for the highly caries
- susceptible patient. J Prosthet Dent
1992;67:637-44.
-
Larmas M. Saliva and dental caries: diagnostic tests
for nor- mal practice. Int Dent J 1992;42:199-208.
-
Kidd EA. The use of diet analysis and advice in the
man- agement of dental caries in adult patients. Oper Dent 1995;20:86-93.
-
Hicks MJ, Flaitz C, Silverstone LM. Secondary caries
for- mation in vitro around glass ionomer restorations. Quin tessence Int
1986;17:527-32.
-
Benelli EM, Serra MC, Rodrigues AL Jr, Cury JA. In situ
anticariogenic potential of glass ionomer cement. Caries Res 1993;27:280-84.
-
Kidd EA. Role of chlorhexidine in the management of
den- tal caries. Int Dent J 1991;41:279-86.
-
Addy M, Slayne MA, Wade WG. The formation and control of
dental plaque - an overview. J Appl Bacterid 1992;73:269-78.

|