Dental Health Care At the Disabled Children's Rehabilitation
Center in Riyadh
Joseph O. Adenubi, BDS, MSc, MPH*, Paris H. Saleem, FRCP (Edin), DCH**
Josielyn N. Martinez, DMD**
*College of Dentistry, King Saud University, P.O.Box 60169, Riyadh 11545, Saudi Arabia.
**Disabled Children's Rehabilitation Center, Riyadh.
Sixty-six disabled children, 3 to 14 years old, attending the Disabled
Children's Rehabilitation Center (DCRC) in Riyadh between March 1993
and July 1994 were evaluated before and after treatment. The types of
dental problems found in the disabled child, the causes of the
handicap, the pattern of dental treatment carried out and the
management techniques used in providing care are reported. Personal,
medical and dental data were recorded and analyzed. Main etiologic
factors for disabilities were congenital or due to perinatal events and
78.8% of the children had cerebral palsy. The oral problems included
dental caries 79%, poor oral hygiene 37.8%, bruxism 24% and
malocclusion 15%, The treatment modalities carried out were prophylaxis
in 15%, restorations including pulp therapy in 81.8%, exodontia in
19.7% and interceptive orthodontics in 3%. All types of treatment were
achieved under local anesthesia [LA] with or without restraint.
Premedica-tion such as Vallergan 3.5 mg/kg or Phenergan 1 mg/kg body
weight was used for proper management of the patients. An aggressive
prevention program is recommended along with other proven methods in
the dental care of disabled children. The experiment of making dental
treatment readily available to the disabled children in Riyadh appears
to be succeeding.
Dental management of the handicapped child has received
scant attention in the literature compared with the normal child. Until recent years,
the management of the handicapped child was not even mentioned in the undergraduate
curriculum of most dental schools in different parts of the world. This partly explains
why the handicapped child has not received its fair share of dental management in
the community.
The Department of Health, Education and Welfare of the United States,
in its Rehabilitation Act of 1973' defined a handicapped person as one who has a physical or mental impairment which substantially
limits one or more major life activities such as caring for one's self, performing
manual tasks, walking, seeing, hearing, speaking, breathing, learning and working.
In addition, a handicapped person has a record of such impairment (has a history
of or has been classified as having a condition that limits major life activities);
and is regarded as having such an impairment.
Nowadays, the term "disability" is preferred to the "handicapped".
The term disability refers to any impairment that restricts or limits daily
activity in some manner.2 The disability may be developmental in origin
or acquired.'' Developmental disabilities are handicapping conditions identified
in early childhood and usually persist throughout an individual's life. Etiologic
factors of developmental disabilities are medically broad based and are due to a
variety of conditions which include cerebral palsy, Down's syndrome, mental retardation,
autism, seizure
disorders, hearing and visual impairments, congenital defects, and even social or
intellectual deprivation.3 The acquired disabilities are caused by a disability
factor later in life and include neuromuscular disorders, traumatic injuries, and
psychiatric disorders producing various forms of physical and mental disabilities
in the individual.3
In 1979, the Journal of Dental Education4 published
guidelines for predoctoral dental training in the care of the handicapped. In 1985,
curriculum guidelines for dental students managing patients with minor disabilities5
and a curriculum for general practice residents in care of the developmentally disabled
child were published.6 These events marked the beginning of closer attention
to the dental health of the disabled. In 1990, the Journal of Education published
an updated Curriculum Guidelines for training General Practice residents to treat
a person with a handicap7 as approved by the American Association of
Dental Schools.
A survey of the availability of dental services to the developmentally
disabled residing in a community in north central Florida, USA, showed that dentists
were reluctant to provide services for a variety of reasons including : patient
is too uncooperative, inadequate knowledge and preparation, lack of proper equipment
necessary to treat this group of special patients, and financial disincentives.8
Similar reports abound.9 " The clinical management of special
patients may require additional staff members, extra time, various behavior modification
techniques including physical restraint, and or sedation for which the dentist may
not be reimbursed.8 These factors account for why the disabled child
has difficulty in obtaining dental treatment in most of the world.
In 1988. in Riyadh, the capital of the Kingdom of Saudi
Arabia, the Welfare Association for Handicapped Children now known as the Saudi
Benevolent Association for Handicapped Children, - as a charity foundation, - established
a Handicapped Children's House [HCH] which is now called the Disabled Children's
Rehabilitation Center [DCRC]. The primary objective of the center is to render a
comprehensive care for disabled children from birth to the age of 12 years. The
center functions both as a medical center and as a school in addition to rehabilitation
of the children. It also serves to assist the families of the children to accept
the facts of retardation. The state of the art medical facilities in the center
include a pediatric dental clinic where this study was carried out.
The purposes of this study were to describe the types of
dental problems found in the disabled child in the Disabled Children's Rehabilitation
Center [DCRC], collate the causes of handicapped children, determine the pattern
of dental treatment carried out on the disabled children- both curative and preventive
and to catalogue the management techniques used in providing dental care.
In a prospective study, all the handicapped children who
attended the Pediatric Dental Clinic at the DCRC in Riyadh between March 1993 and July 1994 were evaluated
from their first visit till treatment was completed by the pediatric dentist. The
following information on each child was recorded.
- Age, sex, medical diagnosis
of the handicap, the cause, type of disability, and extra-oral findings.
- Intra-oral findings
included state of oral hygiene, periodontal disease, dental caries, trauma to anterior
teeth, malocclusion, bruxism, supernumerary teeth or missing teeth, and tooth discolorations.
- Types of dental treatments
carried out.
- Behavioral management
technique.
Details on the medical history of each child were obtained
from the hospital file and at regular meetings with the physician, surgeon and pediatrician
when necessary. The pediatric dentist recorded all the data relevant to clinical
dentistry as management progressed to completion. These data were later analyzed.
The clinical findings and treatment carried out by the pediatric
dentist are presented in Tables 1-6. There were 39 boys and 27 girls who attended
for treatment during the period of the study for a total of 66. Nearly half [30]
were between the age of 3 and 5 years and two of the children were 14 years old
though the center normally looks after children from birth to age 12 years (Table
1).
Medical diagnosis (Table 2) showed that 52 (78.8%) of the
children treated had cerebral palsy, two were epileptic, one with Spina Bifida while
others (II) constitute 16.7%.
Table 3 presents the etiology of the disability and medical
diagnosis of the 66 children, 34 of which are congenital or unknown while prematurity,
birth asphyxia and forceps delivery accounted for 39%.
Table 4 shows that 25 children or 37.8% had poor oral hygiene.
As many as 15% had good oral hygiene while 39.4% were ranked fair. Overall, calculus
was present in 3 males and 1 female with the age-group 9 years and above.
Fifty five or 83.3% of the children examined and treated
had no gingivitis while 10 (15.2%) had. It was only in one child that gingivitis
had advanced to periodontal disease.
Fifty two (79%) of the children had dental caries with 35
(53%) in the posterior teeth only, while 13 (20%) had caries in both anterior and
posterior teeth. Four children (6%) had caries in the anterior teeth only and all
the caries were in the upper jaw.
Malocclusion was present in 10 (15%) of the children with
anterior open bite being the most common form of malocclusion (Table 5). Excessive
overbite and overjet in the anterior teeth as well as unilateral crossbite in the
posterior teeth also occurred. One child had both excessive overjet and protrusion
of the upper anterior teeth.
Three out of 39 boys (7.7%) and one out of 27 girls (3.7%)
or 4 out of 66 children [6%] had traumatized anterior teeth. Bruxism was present
in nearly one out of four (24.2%) of the disabled children. One 11-year-old child
had a mesiodens, another had teeth #83 and 84 missing while a third child had
two fused teeth, #72 and 73 as well as #82 and
83.
Often, the child is mentally retarded and presents the problems
of behavioral management. A typical child, x generally, does not sit
back in the dental chair and would frequently move forward or even attempt to get
out of the chair. The child also may not respond to requests to open his or her
mouth and when the mouth is opened, the child may close it on any instrument or
the handpiece applied to the mouth.
It was therefore necessary to use restraint with the cooperation
of the parents and the dental assistant. In most cases, this was inadequate and
the use of premedication together with "Pedi Wrap" and mandatory
use of local anesthesia were necessary. Vallergan at the dose of 3.5 mg/kg body
weight or Phenergan (1 mg/kg body weight) were the drugs used as intraoral premedication
one hour before treatment to ensure that each child was well prepared to allow adequate
dental treatment.
Table 6 shows the types of treatment carried out on all
the children seen at the pediatric dental clinic of the center. Fifty-four (81.8%)
of the children had their teeth restored while 13 [19.7%] had their teeth extracted.
Interceptive orthodontics occurred only in 2 children. The restorations carried
were mostly amalgam and glass ionomer cements and, to a lesser extent, composites
and stainless steel crowns. Pulp treatment consisted of 8 pulpotomies in primary
molars and 3 pulpotomies in anterior primary teeth.
Nearly 80% of the children treated have cerebral palsy with
most of them presenting as being both mentally retarded and physically disabled.
Therefore, they all presented problems in behavioral management. The etiology of
these mishaps as earlier reported in a review by Tesini and Felton3 are due to congenital,
natal and perinatal causes.
It is typical of disabled children to have poor oral hygiene
and periodontal disease particularly in the mentally retarded due to lack of proper
oral hygiene.12 ~25 The oral hygiene and periodontal disease
findings in this study are not typical of the literature. This is due to the special
preventive program at the DCRC in Riyadh.
This program includes a weekly demonstration of oral hygiene instructions to the
children and the aids or teachers who directly supervise to help carry out the oral
hygiene procedures on the children. This study supports the reports of Nicolai and
Tesini26 that the oral hygiene of institutionalized mentally retarded
individuals can be improved through the training of direct care staff. Calculus
was found in only 4 children- 3 boys and one girl, all aged 9 years and above.
Dental Caries & Malocclusion
The findings that 79% of the children had caries while 15%
had malocclusion reflect the other major problems of the disabled child in addition
to poor oral hygiene and periodontal disease.x,3-,SJ8'22-23'2528
Bruxism
The
phenomenon of bruxism, which is defined as non-functional contact of the teeth and
includes clenching, quashing, grinding and tapping of the teeth,3 occurred
in 24.2% of the children. This is in agreement with studies that reported bruxism
to be practiced with much greater frequency in children and adults with developmental
disabilities30 compared with approximately 15% of normal school-aged children.3
Treatment Carried Out
Due to the major problem of dental caries, 81.8% of the children needed and
had restorations in their teeth. Only 19.7% had extractions. The typical situation
in different parts of the world is that of neglect of the disabled child such that
most of the caries is untreated with very poor oral hygiene.101217-21"23
In this study, all the children had their restoration needs met and more than half
of them have good or fair oral hygiene. This appears to be an indication of proper
oral health care by the parents, the supervising staff at the center and the dental
team of dental hygienist and pediatric dentist who are all responsible for an aggressive
prevention program for the children. Appliance therapy in interceptive orthodontics
was reduced to minimum and was often avoided to prevent any complications that may
arise from the use of an orthodontic appliance.
Preventive Program for
Children at the DCRC
After the medical diagnosis of the disabled child, members of the dental
staff confer with the physician, surgeon, pediatrician, speech therapist, psychologist,
dietician, physical therapist, and occupational therapist. The primary objective
is to combine their efforts to diagnose, treat, and assess the problems of treatment
of each child admitted into the center. This is followed by regular meetings to
continually assess the progress and treatment needs of each child. The pediatric
dentist effects all operative treatment needed by each child using various behavior
modification techniques of restraint and conscious sedation. Since most of the children
with mental retardation cannot perform the oral hygiene procedures themselves but
always require the assistance of a supervisor or aid in the school, and parent/guardian
at home, the dental hygienist carries out a Special Preventive Program as follows.
A.
In the classrooms of children admitted to the center :
- Weekly Oral Health Education [OHE] to supervising staff
[i.e. aids or direct care staff] and to the few children in each class who may be able to help themselves.
- Weekly individualized
hygiene instructions.
- Step by step demonstration of oral hygiene procedures to
small groups of children and direct care staff who are called aids in DCRC. This
procedure includes teaching of preventive techniques such as positioning of the
child, toothbrushing, and flossing where appropriate.
- Use of disclosing solution to highlight areas of poor oral
hygiene on the teeth.
- Dietary counselling
to supervising staff.
- Providing continual Oral Health Instructions [OHI] to aids
and teachers. This is sometimes complimented by the use of audio-visual material.
B.
In the dental clinic of the center :
- Initial prophylaxis.
- Monthly application
of topical fluoride.
- Periodic scaling and
prophylaxis.
- Continuous motivation of children who can cope with special
toothbrushes.
- Continuous motivation of the accompanying aid [direct care
staff].
- Motivation of the parents when the
children are discharged and attend the clinic
from home.
This report on the disabled children at the DCRC in Riyadh suggests that the objectives
of the center are being achieved and that the experiment of Special Prevention Programs
for the children is succeeding. The regimen of an aggressive prevention program
as practiced in this center is recommended along with other proven methods in the
dental care of disabled children. As reported in earlier studies particularly from
Scandinavia, the major thrust in the management
of the oral health of the disabled child should be prevention. 17-26,31~36
The center's existing prevention
program
embraces patient education when the child is trainable, as well as training of parents
and staff, integration of oral health care into the day to day life of the child
and regular preventive professional care which includes orthodontic and nutritional
preventive services. This concept is similar to the prevention protocols recently
recommended by Tesini and Fenton.
The experiment of making dental treatment readily available
to the disabled child in Riyadh
appears to be succeeding. This has encouraged the Saudi Benevolent Association for
the disabled children to proceed with the establishment of a similar DCRC in Jeddah.
-
U.S. Department of Health, Education and Welfare. Federal Register
Part IV. Washington
DCGovernment Printing Office 1977;42:226-78.
-
National Institute on Disability and Rehabilitation Research.
Disability Statistics. Rehab Brief 1993;14:1-4.
-
Tesini DA, Fenton SJ. Oral health needs of person with physical
or mental disabilities. Dent Clin North Am 1994;38:483-98.
-
Bentz GH. Curriculum guidelines for dentistry for the handicapped.
J Dent Educ 1979;2:637-41.
-
Curriculum guidelines for dentistry for the person with
a handicap. J Dent Educ 1985;49:118-22.
-
Jolly D, Brody H, Glassman P. Dental services for persons
with developmental disabilities. A curriculum for general practice residents. Spec
Care Dent 1987;7(4).
-
Curriculum guidelines for Training General Practice Residents
to treat the person with a handicap. J Dent Educ 1990;54:293-96.
-
Burtner AP, Jones JS, McNeal DR, Low DW. A survey of the
availability of dental services to developmentally disabled persons residing in
a community. Spec Care Dent 1990;10:182-84.
-
Block WJ, Walken JW. Effect of an extramural program on
student attitudes towards dental care for the mentally retarded persons. Am J Ment
Defic 1980;85:262-67.
-
Stiefel DJ, Shaffer SM, Bigelow C. Dentists availability
to treat the disabled patient. Spec Care Dent 1981;1:244-49.
-
Nowak AJ. Dental care for handicapped patient, past, present,
future. Dentistry for the Handicapped. St. Louis:CV Mosby, 1976;3-20.
-
Snyder JR, Knopp JJ, Jordan WM. Dental problems of non-institutionalized
mentally retarded children. Northwest Dent 1960;39:123-33.
-
Magnusson G, De Val R. Oral conditions in a group of children
with cerebral palsy. Odont Rev 1963;14:385-402.
-
Smith CE, Williams JE, Lloyd JL. Dental health status of
the mentally retarded in an institution population. J Tenn Dent Assoc 1966;46:138-46.
-
Fishman SR, Young WD, Haley JB. The status of oral health
in cerebral palsy children and their siblings. J Dent Child 1967;34:219-27.
-
Butts JE. Dental status of mentally retarded children. A
survey of the prevalence of certain dental conditions in mentally retarded children
in Georgia. J Publ Health Dent 1967;27:195-211.
-
Goyings
ED, Rieske DM. The periodontal condition of institutionalized children: Improvement
through oral hygiene. J Publ Health Dent 1968;28:5-15.
-
Swallow JN. Dental disease in children with Down's Syndrome.
J Ment Defic Res 1964;8:102-18.
-
Gullickson JS. Oral findings of mentally retarded children.
J Dent Child 1969;36:59-63.
-
Cutress TW. Dental caries in trisomy 21. Arch Oral Biol
1971;16:1329-44.
-
Murray JJ, McLeod JP. The dental condition of severely subnormal
children in three London Boroughs. Br Dent J 1973:134:380-85.
-
Brown JP, Schodel DR. A review of controlled surveys of
dental disease in handicapped persons. J Dent Child 1976;43:313-20.
-
Tesini DA. An annotated review of the literature of dental
caries and periodontal disease in mentally retarded individuals. Spec Care Dent
1981;1:75-87.
-
Mann J, Wonerman JS, Lavie G, Carlin Y, Garfunkel A. Periodontal
treatment needs and oral hygiene for institutionalized individuals with handicapping
conditions. Spec Care Dent 1984;4:163-66.
-
Thornton JB, Al Zahid S, Campbell VA, Marchetti A, Bradley,
EL Jr. Oral hygiene levels and periodontal disease prevalence among residents with
mental retardation at various residential settings. Spec Care Dent 1989;9:186-90.
-
Nicolaei AB, Tesini DA. Improvement in the oral hygiene
of institutionalized mentally retarded individuals through training of direct care
staff: a longitudinal study. Spec Care Dent 1982;2:217-21.
-
Nowak AJ. Dental disease in handicapped persons. Spec Care
Dent 1984;4:66-9.
-
Vigild M. Prevalence of malocclusion in mentally retarded
young adults. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 1985;13:1183-84.
-
Pieper K, Dirks B, Kessler P. Caries, oral hygiene and periodontal
disease in handicapped adults. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 1986;14:28-30.
-
Perlman S, Friedman C, Tesini DA. Prevention and treatment
considerations for people with special needs. Skillman NJJohnson & Johnson Inc,
1991.
-
Suomi JD. Prevention and control of periodontal disease.
J Am Dent Assoc 1972;83:1271-87.
-
Johnson R, Albertson D. Plaque control for handicapped children.
J Am Dent Assoc 1972;84:824-28.
-
Poulsen S, Agerback N, Melsen V, Korts DC, Glavind L, Rolla
G. The effect of professional tooth cleaning or gingivitis and dental caries in
children after one year. Community Dent Oral Epidemiol 1976;4:195-99.
-
Axelsson P, Lindhe J. The effect of plaque control program
on gingivitis and dental caries in school children. J Dent Res Spec Issue 1977;C56:C142-8.
-
Axelsson P, Lindhe J. Effect of controlled oral hygiene
procedures in caries and periodontal disease in adults. J Clin Reriodontol 1978;5:1-17.
-
Stiefel DJ, Rolla RR, Truelove EL. Effectiveness of various
preventive methodologies for use with disabled persons. Clin Prev Dent 1984;6:17-22.

|