|
Professional Satisfaction Among Saudi Dental Students
Zohair Haidar, BDS, MSC, FDS RCS
College of Dentistry, King Saud University, PO Box 60169, Riyadh 11545,
Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.
A study was carried out at King Saud University Dental School to assess
professional satisfaction between senior dental students and interns. A
questionnaire was distributed to all 4th, 5th year students and interns
(males and females). One hundred sixty (160) or 73% of the two hundred
nineteen (219) who received the questionnaires responded.
The results showed that although 15% of those investigated were
dissatisfied with the dental profession, over 94% of all those included
in the study would like to continue their postgraduate education in the
profession. There were no statistical differences between the opinions
of male and female respondents. Cross tabulation of job satisfaction
and taking the right decision in attending dental school, dentistry
being the first choice and advising a friend to take dentistry, were
significant
Dental educators
find it difficult to predict students performance during their study in the dental
school. Part of the problem is attributed to the fact that the best available students
qualify to study Dentistry. Once in the system, however, the students are faced
with a varied curriculum content. They work
long hours under stressful conditions. Standardized admission tests, like
the Dental Aptitude Test (DAT) have failed to account for strong as well as weak
technical performance.1
Job satisfaction
has been described as the "positive emotional state resulting from the appraisal
of one's job or job experiences".12 Job satisfaction is an important
topic to study because of the potential linkages
between work satisfaction and performance, worker physical and mental health, and worker self-esteem.3
Theories
of job satisfaction suggest that it is determined by multiple factors including:
-
Work characteristics
- both the actual and perceived features of the job and its rewards.3-4
-
Worker attributes
- demographic character- istics, emotional well-being, and personality factors.5-6
-
Non-work factors - social interactions, family life
and general life satisfaction.7
Koslowsky et al
in 19748 found various levels of association between over-all job satisfaction
and several factors. Over-all job satisfaction was found to be positively associated
with satisfaction with delivery of dental care, better relations with patients,
and job autonomy. Yablon et al in 19829 found that higher income is another
source of job satisfaction. On the other hand, job stress and lack of personal time
were sources of dissatisfaction.10-11
Assessing the
level of satisfaction among senior dental students
provides a key barometer of the future of dental education in any country. Measures
of satisfaction with the career a student has chosen can be used to identify problems
or issues that can be targeted by dental schools and the profession In order to
enhance the level of Dental education.
Subsequently, this can lead to improvements
in students performance and indirectly produce better dentists.
This study has
been conducted at the College of Dentistry, King
Saud University,
to assess students satisfaction and the desire to continue further in the profession
by pursuing postgraduate studies.
A questionnaire
written in English was distributed to all interns (105 males and females), 5th year
students (60 males and females) and 4th year students (54 males and females). Nineteen
questions were included. Those who filled the form and thus included in the study
were 88 males (55%) and 72 females (45%), a total of 160 participants. Of this number, 45.6% were interns, 30% were 5,h
year students while 4,h year students accounted for 24.4% of the
respondents. Their mean age was 22.37 years,
and the mean GPA was 3.75.
FOXPRO
was utilized to enter data into a computer. To compute one-way and two-way frequencies,
the statistical package for social sciences (SPSS) was used. Chi-square was used
to determine the relationship between the variables.
The distribution
of participants who were included in the study were as follows:
Interns 73 45.6
%
5th year 48 30.0
%
4th year 39 24.4
%
160 100.0%
When asked
about the father's job, the response showed that most parents were businessmen (20.5%)
(Fig. 1), while most participants stated that their mothers were housewives 84.8%
(Fig. 2). Most of the participants were single (82.2%) while those married were
17.2% (Fig. 3).
Eighty-five percent (85%)
said that they were satisfied with the dental profession as a career, while 15%
were dissatisfied. A cross tabulation of job satisfaction with level of students
is shown in Table 1. Chi-square test showed that there was no significant relationship
between satisfaction and year of study (p = .496).
When asked whether they think that
they had made the right decision in going into
the dental school, 82.5% responded in the affirmative, while 17.5% answered
negatively. A cross tabulation of job satisfaction with taking the right decision
in choosing this career is shown in Table 2.
Chi-square test showed that there was a highly significant
relationship between satisfaction and the "right choice", (p =
<.00001). Seventy-seven point five percent (77.5%) of the respondents indicated
that Dentistry was their first choice when applying to the university, while the
rest (22.5%) reported otherwise. A cross tabulation of job satisfaction with Dentistry
being the first choice when applying to the university is shown in Table 3. Chi-square
test showed that there was significant relationship
between satisfaction and "first choice" (p <.05).
When asked whether
they would advice a close friend to choose the dental school for university studies,
63.1% said they would, while 36.9% would not. A cross tabulation of job satisfaction
with advising a friend to choose the dental school is shown in Table 4. Chi-square
showed that there was significant relationship between satisfaction and advice to
a friend, (p = <.001).
Ninety-four
point four percent (94.4%) of participants said they would like to continue postgraduate
studies. Among these, 81.4% prefer to go abroad for that purpose while 18.6% would
like to stay in the country for their postgraduate studies. A cross tabulation of
job satisfaction with plan for further study is shown in Table 5. Chi-square showed that there was no significant relationship
between satisfaction and plan for further study, (p = .777).
There was no significant difference between the attitude
of males and females regarding their plan to do postgraduate studies although the
trend was slightly higher among males.
Moreover, no significant difference
could be found between males and females regarding going abroad for that purpose
or staying in the country, although the trend was slightly higher among females
wanting to stay in the country.
When asked which country would they
go to for their postgraduate studies, 88.7% preferred the U.S.A.,
while 4.8% chose the United Kingdom.
The more popular fields of specialization for
postgraduate studies as stated by the participants were oral surgery (26.1%)
and orthodontics (26.1%), then prosthodontics, (23.9%) with a visible trend for
males to choose oral surgery and for females to select orthodontics.
Job satisfaction
is an indicator of a person's attitude towards
his profession and for the latter affects behavior assessment of job satisfaction.
This relationship has important theoretical and practical implications. The study
reported here was undertaken to measure dental interns' and senior students' attitudes
towards their profession.
Senior dental students' assessments of the career they have
chosen provide valuable insights about issues in the dental curriculum needing attention.
This study assessed professional satisfaction among 160 senior dental students and
interns who are nearing the stage when they have to leave the school to start their
dental career. They had ample time to get acquainted with the nature of their profession.
The fact that no statistical difference was found between
the male and female respondents to any of the questions showed that the criteria
for job satisfaction between Saudi male and female senior dental students and interns
were similar.
Although the majority of those included in the study were
satisfied with the dental profession as a career (85%), only 63.1% said they would
advice a close friend to follow their foot steps in choosing the dental school for
their university education. This dissatisfaction indicator may be related to the
stress dental students and interns are usually under during their course of studies
and training. Working stress is a significant predictor in job satisfaction.12
Al-Qahtani13 in a study aimed at investigating stress and phobia among
Saudi female dental students found that they were more stressed than high school
students. The stress was in a direct constant relationship with phobia and was inversely
related to student level. Behairy et al14 carried out
a survey between Saudi female dentists aimed at assessing the level of job satisfaction.
Their sample was obtained mainly from Riyadh City.
They found that 75% of those included in the study were satisfied with dentistry
as their chosen profession.
The strongest single finding from the present data concerns
the ambition of the vast majority of senior dental students and interns (male and
female) to continue their postgraduate studies. More than 94% percent of respondents
would like to pursue their higher education. This is an interesting finding for
female respondents. The most popular fields selected for specialization were oral
surgery and orthodontics.
The present study showed that the majority of senior dental
students and interns were satisfied with the career they have chosen. A large number
of them (males and females) would like to continue further in the profession by
pursuing graduate studies, mostly abroad. Oral surgery and orthodontics were the
two most popular specialties.
-
Shugans DA, Dimattco RM, Hays RD, Cretin S, Johnson JD.
Professional satisfaction among California
general dentists. J Dent Education 1990; 54(11): 661-669.
-
Locke E. The nature and causes of job satisfaction. In:
Dynette M, ed. Handbook of industrial and organization psychology. Chicago: Raud McNally Co.
(1976),1297-1349.
-
Lawler E. Satisfaction and behavior.
In: Straw B. ed. Psychological foundations of organizational behavior. Santa
Monica: Good Year Pub Co. 1977,90-109.
-
Kalleberg A. Work values and job rewards: A theory of job
satisfaction. Am Social Rev 1997; 42(2): 124-43.
-
Staw B, Rossj. Stability in the midst of change: A dispositional
approach to job satisfaction. J Appl Psychol 1985; 70(3): 469-80.
-
Gutek B. The relative importance of intra psychic determinants
of job satisfaction. In: Duncank, Gruneberg M. Wallis D, ed. changes in working
Chichester England: John Wiley and sons 1980, 521-537.
-
Near JP. Relationships between job satisfaction and life
satisfaction. Test of a causal model. Social Indications Research 1984; 15:351-67.
-
Koslowsky M, Bailit H, Valluzzo P. Satisfaction of the patient and the provider; evaluation by questionnaire.
J Public Health Dent 1974; 31: 188-194.
-
Yablon P., Maykow K.P. Nonchairside factors affecting the
career satisfaction of dentists. J Dent Proct Adm 1984; 42-46.
-
Katz CA. Are you a hardy dentist? The relationship between personality
and stress. J Dent Pract Adm 1987; 4:100-107.
-
O'Shea RM, Corah NL, Ayer WA. Sources of dentist's stress
J Am Dent Assoc 1984; 109: 98-51.
-
Shugars D, DiMatteo R, Hays R. Professional satisfaction
among California
general dentists J Dent Educ 1990; 54: 661-667.
-
Al-Qahtani Z. Stress among female dental students. Internship
seminar presentation (March 1998), King
Saud University,
College of Dentistry.
-
Behairy R, Al Saleen A. A profile of Saudi female dentists. Internship seminar presentation (April 1998), King
Saud University,
College of Dentistry.

|